Watch the video below and see what the judges have to say about his performance:
Randy Jackson: Wrong song for you. Boring and safe for you at the wrong time.
Jennifer Lopez: You can sing anything and you sang that beautifully.
Steven Tyler: I also don’t think it was the right song for you.
If you like DeAndre Brackensick tonight, vote for him at 1-866-IDOLS-05
What do you think of DeAndre’s rendition of the song? Sound off in comments. Don’t forget to take our poll at the right side of this page.
Photo CR: americanidol.com